Our view

Teaching Grammar to Young Learners: Learnt, Not Lectured.

Why we believe children should meet grammar in stories, songs and real exchanges first, and what the research really says about explicit teaching.

Quote on teaching grammar to young learners: knowing a rule and using the language are not the same thing

Picture a Year 3 class. On the board: “Present simple, third person: add -s.” The children copy the rule, fill in ten blanks, and get most of them right. The next day, one of them says: “My brother play football.”

We have seen this scene in classrooms across Morocco for thirty years. It tells us something simple: knowing a rule and using the language are not the same thing. That is why, when it comes to teaching grammar to young learners, our position is clear. Children should meet grammar inside stories, songs and real exchanges first. The rule, if it comes at all, comes later, as a name for something they already do.

The problem

Why “rules first” fails young learners

A rule is an abstraction about language. A seven-year-old does not yet think about language as an object to analyse; they think about what they want to say. Give them the rule first, and you ask them to do the hard part before the easy part.

There is also the question of time. Many Moroccan primary schools give English one to three hours a week. Every minute spent explaining a rule is a minute not spent hearing and using English, and young learners have very few other places to hear it.

Finally, there is the Moroccan context. Our pupils already study French grammar for years, with its conjugation tables and rules to learn by heart. When English arrives as a third language, it should not feel like a second grammar course. It should feel like a new way to say things.

That is the heart of implicit grammar teaching: the structure is always there in the lesson, but the child meets it through meaning, many times, before anyone names it.

In class

Teaching grammar to young learners without rules first

Implicit does not mean accidental. The grammar is planned; only the way children meet it changes. Here is the same target, the present simple with he and she, taught two ways.

Rules firstGrammar in use
StartThe rule on the board, then examplesA short story about a family’s morning, with pictures and audio
PracticeTen gap-fill sentencesChildren act out the story: “She wakes up. He brushes his teeth.”
SpeakingRead the answers aloudPairs describe a classmate’s routine: “Sara plays tennis.”
Correction“Wrong, add -s”The teacher repeats it back correctly: “Yes! Your brother plays football.”
The ruleAt the startAt the end, if the class is ready: “What do you notice about plays, brushes, wakes?”

Five tools make it work in any classroom:

  1. Stories and songs that repeat the same structure many times in a meaningful context. Reading at home helps too: see our guide on how to help your child read in English.
  2. Chunks learnt whole before they are analysed: “Can I have…?”, “I’ve got…”, “There is…”.
  3. Noticing: highlight a pattern in the text and let children find it themselves.
  4. Recasts: answer the child’s mistake by repeating the sentence correctly, without stopping the flow.
  5. Lots of use: speaking games and short tasks where the structure is needed to win or to finish.

Knowing a rule and using the language are not the same thing.

Infographic comparing a rules-first grammar lesson with a grammar-in-use lesson for young learners of English
The same grammar point taught two ways: rules first, or grammar in use.

The research

What we are not saying

An opinion is only worth something if it is honest about the evidence, so here it is. Research does not say that explicit grammar teaching is useless.

So our position is not “never mention grammar”. It is about order and dose:

  • Meaning first. Children meet and use a structure before it is named.
  • Attention inside the lesson, not instead of it. Noticing a pattern in a story is explicit attention too, but it grows out of use, not a lecture.
  • More explanation as children grow. Older pupils preparing for exams such as Cambridge A2 Key or B1 Preliminary benefit from naming and comparing structures. In primary school, the balance should stay firmly on use.

What we reject is the lesson that starts with a rule and ends with a worksheet, and calls that learning English.

For your school

Teaching English in Moroccan primary schools: how to teach grammar

For teachers: plan each lesson around a story, a song or a task, and list the structure it carries in your notes, not on the board. Count how many times each child hears and says it. Correct by recasting, not by stopping.

For coordinators: test what you teach. If lessons are built on use, tests should ask pupils to understand and say things, not to recite rules. A speaking task and a short listening are better evidence than a page of conjugations.

When choosing a coursebook: look for series where grammar is introduced through stories, songs and dialogues, with lots of recycling across units, and where the Teacher’s Book shows how to draw attention to form without a lecture. Most primary courses we distribute, such as Look, Super Minds and Primary Path, are built this way. [Confirm before publishing]

A last word. Grammar matters. Children who never get the structures right will struggle later. But for young learners, the fastest road to correct grammar runs through using English, often and with pleasure, not through talking about it.

Bring this approach to your teachers

Exchanges runs practical trainings on teaching grammar to young learners, on site or online, for schools across Morocco.

See upcoming trainings

The Exchanges view

For young learners, grammar should be met in use first: stories, songs, dialogues and tasks. The rule comes later, as a name for what pupils already do, with more explicit attention as they grow and prepare for exams. Want to bring this approach to your teachers? Exchanges runs trainings on teaching grammar to young learners, on site or online, for schools across Morocco: see the upcoming trainings.

Opinion of Exchanges & Communication.

Frequently asked questions

What is implicit grammar teaching?

Teaching where pupils meet a structure through meaningful use (stories, songs, tasks) many times before the rule is named, if it is named at all.

Is explicit grammar teaching bad for children?

No. Research finds explicit attention helps learners, children included. The question is order and dose: for young learners, meaning and use should come first.

When should teachers explain grammar rules?

After pupils have used the structure, and more as they grow older. Exam preparation such as A2 Key or B1 Preliminary benefits from naming and comparing structures.

Sources

  1. Age and learning environment: Are children implicit second language learners?, Karen Lichtman, Journal of Child Language, 43(3), 2016
  2. Elements of Grammar Instruction, COERLL, University of Texas at Austin, summarising Norris and Ortega (2000), Language Learning

Share this article